Skip to main content

Insights

Criminal law

Criminal charges and permanent residents: why immigration advice comes first

For a permanent resident, a conviction can mean loss of status — and a six-month sentence can remove the right to appeal. Why immigration advice should come first.

Author
By Kang & Company
Published
Reading time
4 min read

For a Canadian citizen, a criminal charge is serious enough on its own. For a permanent resident — or anyone in Canada on a work permit, a study permit or as a visitor — the same charge can carry a second set of consequences under the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA), up to the loss of status and removal from Canada. Those consequences often turn on decisions made early in the criminal case, which is why immigration advice should be part of the defence from the start.

Two grounds of inadmissibility

IRPA sets out several grounds on which a person who is not a Canadian citizen can be found inadmissible to Canada. Two of them deal with criminal offences:

  • Serious criminality (section 36(1)) applies to permanent residents and foreign nationals alike. For an offence in Canada, it covers a conviction for a federal offence punishable by a maximum term of imprisonment of at least 10 years, or a conviction for which a term of imprisonment of more than six months was imposed.
  • Criminality (section 36(2)) applies only to foreign nationals. For an offence in Canada, it covers a conviction for an offence punishable by way of indictment, or convictions for two federal offences that did not arise out of a single occurrence.

Two features of these rules are easy to overlook. First, serious criminality can turn on the maximum sentence an offence carries, not only on the sentence actually imposed. Second, an offence that may be prosecuted either summarily or by indictment — a "hybrid" offence — is treated as indictable for these purposes, even if the Crown proceeded summarily (section 36(3)(a)).

An example: impaired driving

Since December 18, 2018, most impaired driving offences under the Criminal Code have carried a maximum penalty of 10 years' imprisonment on conviction by indictment. The Government of Canada has advised that most impaired driving offences are now considered serious crimes for immigration purposes, and that permanent residents convicted of them may lose their status and have to leave Canada. Because impaired driving is a hybrid offence, that can be so even when the Crown proceeds summarily and the sentence is a fine. For offences committed before December 18, 2018, IRCC assesses inadmissibility using the penalties in force at the time.

The six-month line and the right of appeal

A permanent resident who is found inadmissible and ordered removed can usually appeal the removal order to the Immigration Appeal Division (IAD) of the Immigration and Refugee Board. The IAD may allow the appeal, or stay the removal order, if it is satisfied — taking into account the best interests of a child directly affected — that sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations warrant special relief (sections 67 and 68).

That right of appeal is not always available. Under section 64, there is no appeal to the IAD for a permanent resident found inadmissible for serious criminality where the crime was punished in Canada by a term of imprisonment of at least six months. The thresholds differ slightly: a sentence of more than six months can make a permanent resident inadmissible, while a sentence of six months or more removes the appeal. The difference between a sentence of five months and one of six months can therefore decide whether an appeal is available at all.

A stay of removal is also conditional. If a person whose removal order was stayed is later convicted of another offence amounting to serious criminality, the stay is cancelled by law and the appeal ends (section 68(4)). A permanent resident loses that status when a removal order against them comes into force (section 46(1)(c)).

Why timing matters

Many of the decisions that shape these outcomes are made in the criminal case itself: which charges proceed, whether to plead guilty and to what, and what sentence is proposed and imposed. Once a conviction is entered and a sentence imposed, the immigration consequences largely follow from the record. Before you plead guilty or agree to a resolution:

  • Tell your criminal lawyer your exact immigration status — permanent resident, work or study permit holder, visitor, refugee claimant or protected person.
  • Ask whether the charge, and any proposed plea, could amount to criminality or serious criminality under IRPA.
  • Ask how any proposed sentence compares with the six-month thresholds described above.
  • Keep copies of all Court documents, including the charging document, the record of conviction and the sentencing order.
  • If you already have a conviction, get advice before you travel outside Canada or apply for citizenship.

Other ways a conviction can matter

Convictions outside Canada can also lead to inadmissibility where the offence would be an offence in Canada, and a sponsored family member's criminal record can affect a sponsorship application. Record suspensions and rehabilitation can sometimes remove an inadmissibility, but the rules are technical and change from time to time.

Advice on both sides of the case

If you are not a Canadian citizen and you have been charged with an offence, get advice on both the criminal and the immigration side of your matter before you decide how to resolve the charge. Several of our lawyers practise in both criminal law and immigration law, and files are handled collaboratively.

This article is general information, not legal advice. The law may have changed since it was published on August 12, 2026. For advice about your own situation, speak to a lawyer. Read our disclaimer.