Skip to main content

Our cases

History & prominent cases.

We are proud to have acted on high-profile cases as well as salt-of-the-earth cases. Here are four prominent cases we were privileged to act on since the firm was founded in 1991.

Each is set out with links to the public record — the judgments, where there are any — and to the coverage at the time. More decisions are listed on Reported decisions, and more coverage on Media coverage.

01: Extradition

India v. Singh

Years
1994–1996
Court
Supreme Court of British Columbia (Oliver J.)
Citation
1996 CanLII 17926 (BC SC); 108 C.C.C. (3d) 274
Outcome
Committal for extradition denied, 19 April 1996
Counsel

With Les Mackoff.

The Government of India asked a British Columbia Court to commit our client for extradition on a charge of conspiracy to murder. The Court refused — and, in doing so, considered the Criminal Code’s bar on statements obtained by torture, for what counsel believed was the first time in a Canadian Court.

India sought our client on a single charge: conspiracy to murder Sant Harchand Singh Longowal, who was killed in August 1985. Its case rested on the confessional statements of five people who had been held in detention in India for about ten years.

Mr. Justice Oliver found that, even taking every statement as admissible, there was no evidence on which a reasonable jury could convict, and that India had not established a prima facie case. The application for a warrant of committal was denied.

The Court also excluded one of the confessions, finding on a balance of probabilities that it had been obtained by torture and was inadmissible under s. 269.1(4) of the Criminal Code. As far as counsel could determine, it was the first time a Canadian Court had considered that provision.

Narindar acted for our client with Les Mackoff, at the Court of Appeal’s review of bail in 1995 and at the extradition hearing in 1996.

In any proceedings over which Parliament has jurisdiction, any statement obtained as a result of the commission of an offence under this section is inadmissible in evidence, except as evidence that the statement was so obtained.
Criminal Code, s. 269.1(4) (opens in a new tab)

Timeline

  1. December 1994

    Arrest and bail

    Our client is arrested on a warrant of apprehension and refused bail.

  2. February 1995

    Bail review

    The Court of Appeal for British Columbia confirms the refusal of bail (1995 CanLII 1362 (opens in a new tab)).

  3. 19 April 1996

    Committal denied

    Oliver J. denies India’s application for committal (1996 CanLII 17926 (opens in a new tab)).

The record

02: Criminal defence

Air India

R. v. Malik and Bagri

Years
2000–2005
Court
Supreme Court of British Columbia (Josephson J.)
Citation
2005 BCSC 350
Outcome
Both accused found not guilty on all counts, 16 March 2005
Counsel

For Ajaib Singh Bagri, with the defence team led by Richard Peck, Q.C.

On 23 June 1985, Air India Flight 182 was destroyed by a bomb over the Atlantic, and all 329 people on board were killed. Fifteen years later, two British Columbia men were charged. The firm acted for one of them, Ajaib Singh Bagri, who was acquitted at trial.

The RCMP arrested Mr. Bagri and Ripudaman Singh Malik on 27 October 2000. Narindar S. Kang, KC, acted for Mr. Bagri from the time of his arrest — in November 2000 The Globe and Mail described him as Mr. Bagri’s lawyer — and stayed on the defence team when Richard Peck, Q.C. took the lead.

Narindar and Ajeet K. Kang, KC, appeared for Mr. Bagri (“N. Kang and A. Kang” in the Court’s reasons) at the bail hearing in December 2000 and January 2001, at which both accused were ordered detained. Ajeet is listed, as “A. Kang”, among Mr. Bagri’s counsel in the trial judgment.

Narindar travelled in the wake of the tragedy of 9/11 to India on behalf of the accused in order to further the defence strategy in the case. He met with individuals in detention in India under draconian laws such as the TADA (Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act). He liaised with potential defence witnesses and with lawyers engaged locally. This required heavy security arrangements in order to advance the defence of the accused, but was deemed necessary. Probative evidence to the defence was thereafter disclosed to the Crown, resulting in the Crown resiling from its position to call certain witnesses at trial.

The trial began in April 2003 and ran for about sixteen months. On 16 March 2005, Mr. Justice Josephson found both accused not guilty on each count of the indictment. With an investigation and prosecution that spanned nearly twenty years, it was one of the most expensive prosecutions in Canadian history.

[A]ll parties agree that this trial will be of an unprecedented and massive scope.
Josephson J., 2001 BCSC 1758, para. 2 (opens in a new tab)

Timeline

  1. October 2000

    Arrest

    Mr. Bagri and Mr. Malik are arrested and charged in connection with the bombing.

  2. January 2001

    Bail hearing

    Narindar and Ajeet appear for Mr. Bagri; both accused are ordered detained (2001 BCSC 2 (opens in a new tab)).

  3. December 2001

    Trial scheduling

    Narindar is listed among Mr. Bagri’s counsel on the Court’s ruling on the conduct of the trial (2001 BCSC 1758 (opens in a new tab)).

  4. April 2003

    Trial begins

    The trial opens before Mr. Justice Josephson and runs for about sixteen months.

  5. 16 March 2005

    Verdict

    Both accused are found not guilty on all counts (2005 BCSC 350 (opens in a new tab)).

The record

In the media

  1. The Globe and MailArticle

    Air India suspect denied legal aid (The Globe and Mail, 7 November 2000; opens in a new tab)

    By Robert Matas. Names Narindar S. Kang, KC, as Mr. Bagri’s lawyer.

  2. The Globe and MailArticle

    Air-India trial ends (The Globe and Mail, 4 December 2004; opens in a new tab)

    Reports the close of the trial, after 233 Court days of testimony.

Narindar’s travel to India in September 2001, and the disclosure to the Crown that followed, are the firm’s own account.

03: Refugee advocacy

The Ocean Lady

Years
2009
Forum
Immigration Division, Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (detention reviews)
Outcome
Release orders for detained asylum seekers, December 2009
Counsel

Narindar as counsel, with Jas as co-counsel.

In October 2009, 76 Tamil asylum seekers were found aboard a cargo ship, the Ocean Lady, off the coast of British Columbia, and taken into custody. All of them claimed refugee protection. The firm helped organize their legal team, without charge.

Through the Ocean Lady Legal Consortium, the firm provided pro bono legal assistance from 18 October 2009, including representation in initiating refugee claims, and helped organize the legal team for their detention reviews at the Immigration Division of the Immigration and Refugee Board, without charge. Thereafter, approximately 23 individuals were represented by the firm in order to secure release orders; roughly half of the clients the firm acted for were pro bono. Narindar S. Kang, KC, acted as counsel, with Jas Mattoo as co-counsel.

By 24 December 2009, 23 release orders had been issued. Narindar told CBC News that more were coming, and that there were no grounds for their continued detention. Two days later, he told The Canadian Press that those being released would be allowed to settle with family members already living in Canada.

The following summer, as another ship carrying Tamil asylum seekers, the MV Sun Sea, approached, the Toronto Star quoted Narindar, a former Immigration Judge, on what international law requires for people with a well-founded fear of persecution. The firm’s wider pro bono work is set out on Pro Bono & Teaching.

Timeline

  1. October 2009

    Arrival

    76 Tamil asylum seekers aboard the Ocean Lady are taken into custody in British Columbia.

  2. 18 October 2009

    The legal consortium

    The firm begins pro bono work through the Ocean Lady Legal Consortium, and helps organize the legal team without charge.

  3. December 2009

    Release orders

    23 release orders have been issued, with more expected.

  4. 2009–2011

    Refugee claims

    The consortium’s pro bono work continues, including initiating their refugee claims.

The record

In the media

  1. CBC NewsArticleArchived copy

    More Tamil migrants set for release (CBC News, 24 December 2009; opens in a new tab)

    Quotes Narindar S. Kang, KC, on the release orders.

  2. The Canadian Press, on CTV NewsArticleArchived copy

    50 detained Tamil migrants to be released: Lawyer (The Canadian Press, on CTV News, 26 December 2009; opens in a new tab)

    Quotes Narindar S. Kang, KC.

  3. Impunity Watch, Syracuse UniversityArticle

    50 Tamil Migrants to be Released From Custody (Impunity Watch, Syracuse University, 27 December 2009; opens in a new tab)

    Names Narindar S. Kang, KC, among the lawyers for the 76 migrants.

  4. Toronto Star, reproduced by SafeComArticle

    Refugee ship could be boarded by US or Canada (Toronto Star, reproduced by SafeCom, 28 July 2010; opens in a new tab)

    Quotes Narindar S. Kang, KC, as a former Immigration Judge, on the MV Sun Sea.

Detention reviews at the Immigration Division are not published with the parties’ names, and no published decision names our clients or our lawyers, so there is no judgment to link. Jas Mattoo’s role as co-counsel, the number of people the firm represented and the share it acted for pro bono are the firm’s own account.

04: Spousal sponsorship

The Basanti case

Years
2018–2023
Forum
Immigration Appeal Division (2018 ruling); permanent residence decided by an immigration officer
Outcome
Permanent residence granted after five earlier refusals
Counsel

Narindar at the Immigration Appeal Division in 2018, with Tony Manglaviti; Nimrita and her team at the firm through to permanent residence.

A Surrey man and his wife spent more than two decades of their marriage on different continents, as one application after another was refused. Narindar S. Kang, KC, acted for the couple at the Immigration Appeal Division, and Nimrita Kaur Kang and her team saw the case through to permanent residence.

Paramjit Basanti, a Canadian citizen living in Surrey, married Charanjit in February 1999. Five applications to sponsor her were refused: the first four because officials did not accept that the marriage was genuine, and the fifth because the couple’s representative at the time had conceded, in 2001, that immigration was the marriage’s primary purpose — a concession that became disqualifying after a rule change in 2010.

Because the Immigration Appeal Division had dismissed the couple’s earlier appeals, their next appeal first had to overcome the doctrine of res judicata. In April 2018, with Narindar as counsel alongside Tony Manglaviti, the Division ruled that the long marriage and the events since 2005 were special circumstances justifying an exception, so that the appeal could be heard on its merits (2018 CanLII 54740 (opens in a new tab)).

As the pandemic worsened in India in 2021, the couple’s case was before officials again: a sixth application had been filed, and Nimrita and her team were seeking ministerial intervention for a temporary resident permit.

Charanjit was approved as a permanent resident, and in July 2023 the couple were reunited at Vancouver International Airport, after 24 years of marriage. As Nimrita explained to CBC News, what made the difference was an adjudicator who considered the whole history: decades of applications, and the evidence that the relationship had endured.

Narindar appears in the video CBC News published with its report of the reunion, and later that month the couple and their lawyers spoke about the case, in Punjabi, with Harjinder Thind on RED FM.

Timeline

  1. February 1999

    Married

    Paramjit and Charanjit marry. Five sponsorship applications are refused in the years that follow.

  2. 26 April 2018

    A preliminary ruling

    The Immigration Appeal Division rules that special circumstances justify an exception to res judicata, so the couple’s appeal can be heard on its merits (2018 CanLII 54740 (opens in a new tab)).

  3. December 2019

    Twenty years apart

    CBC News reports on the couple’s years of separation.

  4. May 2021

    A sixth application

    Nimrita’s team seeks ministerial intervention while a new application is considered.

  5. July 2023

    Reunited

    Charanjit arrives in Canada as a permanent resident.

The record

In the media

A Punjabi-language video (14:57): the couple and their lawyers, Narindar S. Kang, KC, and Nimrita Kang, are the guests of host Harjinder Thind.Watch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)The player loads from YouTube when you press play.

The 2018 ruling decided a preliminary question, not the appeal itself. Permanent residence was later granted on an application decided by an immigration officer, not a Court judgment, so there is no published decision to link for it.