Skip to main content

Federal Court — Immigration Matters

When an immigration officer or the Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada decides against you, the Federal Court of Canada can be asked to review the decision. Our Federal Court practice, headed by Narindar S. Kang, KC, Rajveer (Raj) Singh Atwal and Rajdev Singh Johal, acts on applications for leave and judicial review of immigration and citizenship decisions, and on applications for a writ of mandamus where a decision has been unreasonably delayed.

Last reviewed

Matter arising in Canada
15 days to file
Matter arising outside Canada
60 days to file
Citizenship Act decision
30 days to file
First step
The Court must grant leave
If the application succeeds
Usually, a new decision

The time limit runs from the day you are notified of, or otherwise become aware of, the decision. Contact us as soon as you receive a refusal — before you take any further steps.

What we handle

The Federal Court reviews decisions made under the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act and the Citizenship Act. Our Federal Court practice covers:

Visitor visas, work permits and study permits

There is no appeal of these refusals to the Immigration Appeal Division. The choice is usually between a new application that addresses the officer’s concerns and an application for leave and judicial review. We review the officer’s reasons and advise which is the better course.

Immigration and Refugee Board decisions

The Court reviews decisions of all four divisions of the Board — the Refugee Protection Division, the Refugee Appeal Division, the Immigration Division and the Immigration Appeal Division — including decisions on refugee claims, admissibility, detention and immigration appeals. Where the Act gives a right of appeal, such as an appeal from the Refugee Protection Division to the Refugee Appeal Division, that appeal must be used first. For a decision of the Board, the time limit is counted from the notice of the decision or the sending of its written reasons, whichever is later.

For appeals to the Immigration Appeal Division itself, see Immigration Appeals; for refugee claims, see Refugee Protection Claims.

Permanent residence refusals

Refusals of applications for permanent residence — for example under Express Entry, or on humanitarian and compassionate grounds — can be challenged by an application for leave and judicial review. Where the refusal can be appealed to the Immigration Appeal Division, as a refused family class sponsorship usually can, the appeal comes first: see Sponsorship Appeal.

Pre-Removal Risk Assessments

A Pre-Removal Risk Assessment (PRRA) is an application for protection made to the Minister by a person in Canada who is subject to a removal order in force. A negative PRRA decision can be challenged by an application for leave and judicial review; because the person is in Canada, the 15-day limit will normally apply. Any stay of removal that applied while the PRRA was being decided ends when the application is rejected, so the application for leave does not by itself stop removal — see If removal is scheduled.

Citizenship decisions

The Court also reviews decisions made under the Citizenship Act, such as refusals of applications for a grant of citizenship, for proof of citizenship and for resumption of citizenship, and a citizenship judge’s decision not to approve an application. The Act gives no appeal of these decisions: they can be challenged by an application for leave and judicial review.

The time limit is different from the limit for immigration matters. The application for leave must be filed and served within 30 days after the day you are notified of, or otherwise become aware of, the decision, whether you are in Canada or outside it. A judge may allow more time for special reasons. The application then follows the same Court rules as an immigration application.

Revocation of citizenship follows its own process. Before citizenship can be revoked for false representation, fraud or knowingly concealing material circumstances, the Minister must send a written notice. You then have 60 days after the day the notice is sent, or any longer time the Minister allows for special reasons, to make written representations, and you may ask that the Minister decide the case. Otherwise the Minister must refer the case to the Federal Court, which decides it in an action, unless your representations satisfy the Minister that citizenship should not be revoked. A revocation decision made by the Minister can be challenged by an application for leave and judicial review.

How an application proceeds

  1. Step 1: Application for leave

    The application is filed with the Court and served on the Minister within 15 days for a matter arising in Canada, or 60 days for a matter arising outside Canada (30 days for a decision under the Citizenship Act). It identifies the decision, the relief sought and the grounds. The Court’s filing fee is $50.

  2. Step 2: Applicant’s record

    We then file the decision, the reasons, sworn affidavits and a written argument. The Court’s rules allow 30 days after the application is filed; if you did not have the decision-maker’s written reasons, the Court’s Registry asks for them, and the 30 days run from when they arrive. Because of a backlog, the Court has for now allowed applicants more time.

  3. Step 3: The Minister’s response

    The Minister’s lawyers may file affidavits and a written argument within 30 days, and we may reply within 10 days.

  4. Step 4: Leave is decided on paper

    A judge decides whether to grant leave on the written materials, usually without a hearing. If leave is refused, there is no appeal from that decision.

  5. Step 5: The hearing

    If leave is granted, the hearing is set no sooner than 30 days and no later than 90 days afterwards, unless the parties agree to an earlier date, and the decision-maker sends the Court its record. If a lawyer represents you, you do not need to attend, but you may.

  6. Step 6: Judgment

    The judge decides whether the decision was reasonable and made fairly. If the application succeeds, the decision is usually set aside and sent back to be made again. An appeal to the Federal Court of Appeal is possible only if the judge certifies a serious question of general importance.

What the Court can and cannot do

Judicial review is not a new hearing of your application. The Court reviews the decision that was made: whether its reasoning holds together and is justified by the facts and the law that were before the decision-maker, and whether the process was fair.

The Court can

  • Set aside the decision and send it back to be decided again, with any directions it considers appropriate
  • Order an officer or tribunal to do something it has unlawfully failed or refused to do, or has unreasonably delayed in doing — the basis of mandamus
  • Make interim orders while the application is pending, such as an order staying a removal

The Court does not

  • Approve your application or, as a general rule, decide it in place of the decision-maker
  • Reweigh the evidence that the decision-maker considered
  • Consider new evidence that was not before the decision-maker, except in limited cases

Success at the Federal Court usually means a new decision, not an approval. The new decision may be the same as, or different from, the first.

Writ of mandamus

Sometimes the problem is not a refusal but silence: an application that has been waiting much longer than the process requires. Where the decision-maker has a legal duty to decide and has unreasonably delayed, the Federal Court can issue a writ of mandamus — an order compelling the decision to be made. Mandamus compels a decision; it cannot dictate what the decision will be.

The Federal Court of Appeal set out the requirements in Apotex Inc. v. Canada (Attorney General), [1994] 1 FC 742, and restated them in Benison v. Royal Canadian Mounted Police External Review Committee, 2026 FCA 53 (opens in a new tab). In plain terms:

  • There is a public legal duty to make the decision, and it is owed to you
  • You have met every condition for the decision — for example, you have provided everything the office asked for
  • You asked for a decision, a reasonable time passed, and the decision-maker refused, either expressly or by unreasonable delay
  • Where the decision involves discretion, mandamus can require the decision-maker to decide, but not to decide in a particular way
  • No other adequate remedy is available
  • The order would have some practical value or effect
  • There is no equitable bar to the order, and the balance of convenience favours it

Every requirement must be met. In deciding whether a delay is unreasonable, the Court asks whether it has been longer than the nature of the process requires, whether you or your representative caused it, and whether the decision-maker has given a satisfactory justification for it.

A mandamus application starts with an application for leave, like any other. Because there is no decision yet, there are no reasons for the Court to request, so the time to file the supporting record runs from the day the application is filed. If a decision is made while the application is pending and it is a refusal, that refusal is a new decision, with its own time limit to challenge it.

Time limits and extensions

Matter arising in Canada
15 days
Matter arising outside Canada
60 days
Citizenship Act decision
30 days, in or outside Canada
Decision of the Board
Counted from the notice or the written reasons, whichever is later
Extension of time
Only for special reasons

The time runs from the day you are notified of, or otherwise become aware of, the decision — not from the day you find a lawyer. For an immigration matter, which limit applies depends on whether the matter arose in Canada or outside it, and the answer is not always obvious. Until a lawyer has advised you, assume the shorter one.

A judge may allow more time for special reasons. The request is made in the application for leave itself and is decided with it. The Court looks at whether you intended throughout to challenge the decision, whether the case has some merit, whether the delay has prejudiced the other side, and whether there is a reasonable explanation for the delay; the overriding question is whether an extension is in the interests of justice. An extension is never automatic, and a late application does not carry the automatic stay of removal that some applications filed on time do.

If removal is scheduled

Applying for leave does not, by itself, stop a removal from Canada. A removal order is stayed automatically only in limited cases — chiefly where an application filed on time challenges a Refugee Appeal Division decision rejecting a refugee claim, and even then there are exceptions, such as serious criminality. Otherwise, a separate motion asks the Court to stay the removal until the application is decided. The Court discourages last-minute motions that could have been brought earlier, so contact us as soon as you receive a direction to report for removal. See also deferral of removal.

Common questions

From our files

Applications for judicial review in which the firm acted. Summaries are general; follow the links for the full decisions where they were published.

  1. Federal Court2020

    Singh v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration)

    2020 FC 214

    Assessing humanitarian and compassionate considerations by reference to a country where the applicant has no legal status is an error. The assessment must rest on the applicant’s right, at the date of the assessment, to relocate to a particular country — not on what might occur in the future.

    CounselRajveer S. Atwal (Kang & Company), for the applicant

    Application for judicial review allowedRead the decision (PDF) (opens in a new tab)
  2. Federal Court2020

    Federal Court file IMM-4516-19

    The Court held that the Immigration Appeal Division had to give the applicant an opportunity to give oral testimony at a show-cause hearing, and that failing to do so breached the applicant’s right to procedural fairness.

    CounselRajveer (Raj) Singh Atwal

    Procedural-fairness breach found
  3. Federal Court2020

    Federal Court file IMM-24-20

    The applicant’s right to procedural fairness was violated when an interview with the Canada Border Services Agency was turned into an admissibility hearing without notice.

    CounselRajveer (Raj) Singh Atwal

    Removal order set aside
  4. Federal Court2020

    Federal Court file IMM-6225-19

    The visa officer failed to sufficiently consider and assess the evidence the applicant provided in response to a procedural-fairness request.

    CounselRajveer (Raj) Singh Atwal

    Application for judicial review allowed
  5. Federal Court2020

    Federal Court file IMM-6588-19

    The visa officer failed to consider evidence the applicant had provided; the decision was unreasonable and not defensible on the facts and evidence.

    CounselRajveer (Raj) Singh Atwal

    Application for judicial review allowed

Past results are not indicative of future outcomes. Each matter depends on its own facts. Nothing on this site is legal advice or creates a solicitor-client relationship.

Counsel

Counsel in this practice.

The lawyers at Kang & Company who act in Federal Court immigration matters. Files are handled collaboratively, so your matter has the benefit of the whole team.

Meet the full team